Louise Penny Readalikes

Mysteries with Character

Do you love "whodunnits" set in small towns with great characters? Look no further!

Image
Book cover of Little Face by Sophie Hannah, showing an empty rocking horse at the end of a hall.

Simon Waterhouse and Charlie Zailer Novels by Sophie Hannah

Set in a quiet, English town boasting higher-than-average crime rates, this suspenseful police procedural series stars a brilliant and introspective police officer whose personal relationships are as twisty and compelling as the mysteries they investigate.

 


 

Image
Book cover of Cover Her Face by P. D. James.

Adam Dalgliesh Mysteries by P.D. James

This mystery series centers on the intensely cerebral and private Adam Dalgliesh. A detective chief inspector at first, he rises in the ranks as the series unfolds. The series itself changes tenor: although initially offering who-done-it plots focused on solving a puzzling crime, later entries emphasize police procedural elements.


 

 

Image
Book cover of Outfoxed by Rita Mae Brown.

Sister Jane Foxhunting Mysteries by Rita Mae Brown

Set in Virginia's tradition-bound, foxhunting country, this series stars steely septuagenarian sleuth Jane "Sister" Arnold. The plots usually center on the uncivil actions of human characters, assisted occasionally by anthropomorphized animal characters.


 

 

Image
Book Cover of The Sweetness at the Bottom of the Pie by Alan Bradley.

Flavia De Luce Mysteries by Alan Bradley

These charming mysteries set in a post-World War II English village star a precocious, nosy pre-teen living with her family in their ancestral mansion. Flavia identifies murderers using her wits and knowledge of village life.


 

 

Image
Book cover of The Cold Light of Mourning by Elizabeth Duncan.

Penny Brannigan Mysteries by Elizabeth J. Duncan

Penny Brannigan is an ordinary manicure shop owner and expatriate from Canada. Throughout the series, she finds herself in the center of gruesome tales of murder and intrigue. Penny is assisted in her amateur sleuthing by her sidekick and business partner, Victoria Hopkirk.

 


 

Image
Book cover of The Mysterious Affair at Styles by Agatha Christie, showing a bottle of poison.

Hercule Poirot Mysteries by Agatha Christie

This Golden Age mystery series features the eccentric Belgian detective Hercule Poirot as he uses his understanding of human nature to solve crimes. Many of the novels are set in England where Poirot lives, while others are set around the world during his travels.


 

 

Image
Book cover of The Man with a Load of Mischief by Martha Grimes, showing a shadowy man standing in front of a diner.

Richard Jury Mysteries by Martha Grimes

The Richard Jury series, particularly the early books, share a number of similar features with Inspector Armand Gamache mysteries: both are clever police procedurals centered around a puzzle. They also focus on the relationships between a group of characters.


 

 

Image
Book cover of In the Bleak Midwinter by Julia Spencer-Fleming, showing a tree and a house, all covered in snow.

Reverend Clare Fergusson Mysteries by Julia Spencer-Fleming

Readers who appreciate the character building in the Gamache series will find much to love in the Reverend Clare Fergusson mysteries. Personalities are just as important as fingerprints when solving crimes in these intricately plotted, complex novels with a strong sense of place.


 

 

Image
Book cover of The Various Haunts of Men by Susan Hill.

Simon Serrailler Mysteries by Susan Hill

DCI Simon Serrailler leads a complicated personal life in Lafferton, an idyllic small town just outside London. This series combines intricate plotting with gritty detail and complex characterization, simultaneously creating a realistic feel and a protagonist readers will remember.


 

 

Image
Book cover of The Shape of Water by Andrea Camilleri, showing an Italian man. Behind him are tiled buildings on a peninsula.

Salvo Montalbano Mysteries by Andrea Camilleri

Set in the picturesque Sicilian village of Vigata, these charming mysteries star the food-loving Inspector Salvo Montalbano. Expect leisurely-paced tales full of grit and wit.

 


 

Image
Book cover of The Quality of Mercy by Katayoun Medhat.

Milagro Mysteries by Katayoun Medhat

Like Penny’s novels, this evocative mystery series showcases a richly detailed environs and distinctive cultural milieu. Hapless investigator, Franz Kafka, investigates confounding murders and other crimes on a Navajo Reservation in New Mexico.


 

 

Image
Book cover of Blessed is the Busybody by Emilie Richards, showing a small church with a lightning bolt about to strike the steeple.

Ministry is Murder Mysteries by Emilie Richards

Aggie Sloan-Wilcox is the unconventional wife of the local minister. Aggie shines as a complex female protagonist who cares for those around her, whether a family member, a friend, or a helpless animal. Character-driven and heartwarming, this series features a charming small town and intriguing crimes.


 

 

Image
Book cover of A Reconstructed Corpse by Simon Brett.

Charles Paris Mysteries by Simon Brett

Amateur sleuth Charles Paris, who is overly fond of drinking and women, and often out of work, solves crimes steeped in the world of drama. These engaging books are a mix of stage lore, jostling egos, and wry humor.

 

 

 

 

Lil Campbell and Ada Strauss Novels by Charles Atkins

The Lil Campbell and Ada Strauss novels are engaging cozy mysteries, set in small-town Connecticut. They feature senior women as amateur sleuths investigating local murders. The books are light in tone, fast paced, and funny.